Why Did You Do That?

rdf:langString Why Did You Do That?

rdf:langString Why Did You Do That?

rdf:langString Why Did You Do That?

rdf:langString * Lady Gaga * Mark Nilan Jr. * Nick Monson * Paul "DJWS" Blair

rdf:langString Saturday Night Live

rdf:langString * Lady Gaga * Diane Warren * Mark Nilan Jr. * Nick Monson * Paul "DJWS" Blair

rdf:langString "Why Did You Do That?" is a song recorded by American singer Lady Gaga for the 2018 film A Star Is Born and released on the soundtrack of the same name. It was written by Gaga with Diane Warren, Mark Nilan Jr., Nick Monson and Paul "DJWS" Blair, and produced by all but Warren. The song appears in the film during a sequence when Gaga's character, Ally, performs on Saturday Night Live, watched by her husband Jackson (played by co-star Bradley Cooper). Later Jackson berates Ally for selling out with the song's trite lyrics, but she defends it. "Why Did You Do That?" was written to evoke both a retro and a modern feel, and was recorded while Gaga was on her Joanne World Tour. The song is interspersed with the sound of a xylophone and a repetitive chorus and post-chorus. After its release, the track received a great deal of attention for its lyrics, which some critics and fans felt were a critique of pop music. The songwriters defended the track, saying it was specifically written to emphasize that Ally's career was on the rise as Jackson's was declining.